Are You a Chocoholic?
By Dr. Randi Fredricks, Ph.D.
Brain changes in chocoholics that occur when they see or eat chocolate are similar to those in addicts when
they take drugs, scientists say.
British researchers found certain regions of the brain were more active when people who confessed to cravings
were fed or shown pictures of chocolate than in non-cravers.
They also discovered the sight of chocolate contributed significantly to the activation of brain areas associated
with reward, suggesting that dieters could cut their intake by avoiding the sight of foods they particularly desire.
Researchers at the University of Oxford's experimental psychology department carried
out functional magnetic resonance (fMRI) imaging on the brains of eight chocoholics and eight non-cravers.
All participants were women.
The volunteers were shown appetising pictures of chocolate and then fed liquid chocolate while having fMRI
scans.
Among chocolate cravers, greater activity was seen in the medial orbitofrontal cortex, pregenual cingulated
cortex and ventral striatum - regions of the brain known to be involved in pleasure sensation, habit-forming
behaviours and drug addiction.
Damage to the orbitofrontal cortex acquired through brain injury has previously been associated with compulsive
gambling and excessive use of alcohol and drugs.
The fMRI scans also demonstrated the combination of the sight and taste of chocolate produced a stronger response
in both cravers and non-cravers, than either separately.
The researchers concluded that understanding individual
differences in brain responses to very pleasant foods helps in the understanding of the mechanisms that drive the
liking for specific foods and thus intake of those foods.
Sight and flavor combined give a much bigger response than seeing or tasting the food separately. The sight
component is important and complements the flavor.
For example, if you want to limit food intake, you could limit the extent to which you are exposed to the combination of
sight and taste. For example, you could eat in the dark.E ating a desired food without seeing it was a parallel experience to eating food when you
cannot smell it because of having a blocked nose.
This research was significant veause it was the first study to show that there are differences between cravers and
non-cravers in their responses to the sensory components of a craved food in the orbitofrontal cortex,
ventral striatum and pregenual cingulate cortex.
Chocolate craving is very common, but can we actually be addicted to it? Can these powerful urges to eat truly
be classed as an addiction?
We generally crave foods due to external prompts and our emotional state, rather than actual hunger. We tend to
be bored, anxious, or depressed immediately before experiencing cravings, so one way of explaining cravings is
self-medication for feeling miserable.
Chocolate is the most frequently craved food in women, and many women describe themselves as 'chocoholics.'
Chocoholics insist that it is habit-forming, that it produces an instant feeling of well-being, and even that
abstinence leads to withdrawal symptoms.
When we eat sweet and high-fat foods, including chocolate, serotonin is released, making us feel happier. This
partly explains the cravings common in seasonal affective disorder (SAD) and pre-menstrual syndrome.
In many women, the craving occurs on a monthly cycle, which suggests a hormonal basis. A recent report in the
New Scientist magazine suggests people can become overly dependent on the sugar and fat in fast food. Princeton
University researcher Dr. John Hoebel found that rats fed on sugar became anxious when the sugar was removed.
Their symptoms included chattering teeth and the shakes - similar to those seen in people withdrawing from
nicotine or morphine. Dr. Hoebel believes high-fat foods stimulate opioids or "pleasure chemicals" in the
brain. This theory is backed up by many other studies.
Chocolate contains several biologically active ingredients, all of which can cause abnormal behaviors and
psychological sensations like those of other addictive substances. Researchers at the University of Tampere
in Finland found that self-proclaimed chocolate "addicts" salivated more in the presence of chocolate, and
showed a more negative mood and higher anxiety. The researchers state that chocolate addicts show traits of
regular addiction, because they exhibit craving for chocolate, irregular eating behavior, and abnormal moods.
Although there are similarities between eating chocolate and drug use, generally researchers believe that
chocolate "addiction" is not a true addiction. While chocolate does contain potentially mood-altering substances,
these are all found in higher concentrations in other less appealing foods such as broccoli. A combination of
chocolate's sensory characteristics (sweetness, texture and aroma) nutrients, and chemicals, together with
hormonal and mood swings, largely explains chocolate cravings.
Chocolate is seen as "naughty but nice" - tasty, but something which should be resisted. This suggests that
the desire is more likely a cultural phenomenon than a physical one. The inability to control eating may be
a result of inborn traits and today's environment. "Humans used to have to search for food," according to
Baylor College of Medicine researcher Dr. Ken . "Now food searches us out."
We are overwhelmed with advertising, large-scale grocery displays, plenty of high-calorie foods, and an
obsession with thinness. The stress of modern living often makes us turn to food for comfort, then return
to a restrictive diet. The attempt to restrain ourselves before we are satisfied increases the desire for
chocolate.
References (To view, roll mouse over the "References" heading; to hide, click on the heading)
Benford, R., Gough, B. (2006). Defining and defending 'unhealthy' practices: A discourse analysis of chocolate 'addicts" accounts. J Health Psychol, 11(3), 427-440.
Dallard, I., Cathebras, P., Sauron, C., & Massoubre, C. (2001). Is cocoa a psychotropic drug? Psychopathologic study of
a population of subjects self-identified as chocolate addicts. Encephale, 27/i>(2), 181-186.
Rolls, E. T., & McCabe, C. (2007). Enhanced affective brain representations of chocolate in cravers vs. non-cravers. Eur J Neurosci, 26<.i>(4), 1067-1076.